I don't believe this author tried her assignments before publishing this book. If her editor made her, then I think she chose intentionally shorter ones.
In the book, she says you should have about three to fours hours to dedicate to each day's assignment. Each day has its own assignment so essentially each assignment should take three to four hours, right?
Wrong. Since there have been a number of days that I have found myself in this situation, I'll just use my most recent moment as my example.
Day 14 (yes, I'm on Day 14 and I started this project in April). This is apparently day one of my novel. She says everything else was build-up and preparation, this is where we actually do work that is meant to be in our finished novel. This day's assignment is three parts. The first part is writing 20 different first lines for our novel. 20 different ways to begin our novel. The second part is focusing on "Act One" of the story and listing five scenes (and their summaries) we think would be in there. Finally, the third part is choosing one of those scenes and actually writing it.
First off, I ran out of first lines once I got to number six. I managed to list 15. This probably took me an hour, possibly two. Then I came up with five scenes I knew had to be included because I had already written the outline at the start of this project because I was confused. I then summarized them each, briefly. By this point, Starbucks was closing and I had been in there writing for over two hours. I decided to leave the final part for the next day (today).
At five o'clock I entered Starbucks and chose the scene I wanted to write. I chose the very first scene of the novel which meant I had to choose which first line I was going to use. My number eight fit so well with the setting of my first scene that I didn't stress out about which first line to use at all (Thank goodness I kept coming up with ideas after I was stumped at number six).
At 7:53 I realized I really needed to wrap it up because this particular Starbucks closes at eight every night. So it took me three hours to write this scene even when I had the beginning figured out (the hardest part is starting as far as I'm concerned), a general idea of where I wanted the scene to go and every character's purpose in that scene. This book is designed for those who don't even have an idea of what to write when they begin. I had so much of an idea I created an outline, knew my characters' general personalities, and it still took me three hours. Add that to the, minimum, two hours I spent the day before and that's a total of, again minimum, five hours on one day's assignment.
If this were the first assignment I had run into that was like this, I wouldn't be writing this post. Frankly, there are about three other assignments that called for writing a scene that I just flat-out ignored for one reason or another and this
still isn't the first assignment I've come across that takes longer than three hours to finish. The assignment on character biographies took me five days to finish. Each character took about an hour because of the list of detailed questions which was two pages long.
Don't misunderstand my venting. These assignments have been incredibly helpful. The character biographies in particular forced me to understand my characters in ways I hadn't considered would be relevant. I'm just saying the estimation is off.
Way off.